ࡱ> OQN@ $jbjbܡܡ "$ l8 4::(bbbAAA4444444,6 8p4A=AAA4? bb:? ? ? AVbb4? A4? ? 1/ p4. F< .40p444F4*M9? M9p4? Hand out 2 Kidney Machine debate Question who should get the machine? Question what are the priority criteria? Either Go for brainstorming session, giving each participant four pieces of paper to write their priorities on. The collect and arrange in clusters The get the participants to vote on the highest priority clusters. Or Determine a set of priorities on age, marital status, expertise, job, etc (list up to 6) Consider a contradictory case. E.g. woman with 6 kids mentally unstable .  PAGE 1 PAGE 1    #$0JmH0J j0JU jCJUOJQJ !Hs{KNh]h&`#$$a$ !Hs{KN !"#$   * !"#$ . A!X"X#$%Zq,Dd)DHN<  C AB+TYL%|xIM8&F+D0T+4l;QUөTYL%|xIM8&Fte TH &Axԛ tU{ cs45AU5DE""imTQP"6æ%& ˼ M0Ҥ̜Rr}˽f̟;"Ⱥ9o=cYNs+ϚUTcmVSlh%䓸J-4Dcsy76Ƿ=nM>Cm:/X8͝39bə8oPg>LI \̐ic#klqg<&tޥxg.vS]? g]|DASJuV tJ8[N@]~aSo@}E='/GEL*+>4Z1 +kK4j0d zS>~Ёr;=SO@] Lw &ҭ&( ,( zy?VvR-?rԕp\MPGn$@r/<(N#<.~'!ψYQBB]l<%b<*^_OYG<)w1r%E,#bD 72W* lQ&9Xq]> r4 ;p l'A)/lb»-&0og !ޘYFn(\g\Eb2[0=btN q?4+; w~HŸ$$>d.Ul,n_ N$>^ndK1Y.)٫ K-372zg_?;≝`YWY]3Á}{e ^ @(ryb/ ~_YGr Vz(Ȯ=̿G"@^N .$i :,B_х$j "*IB0 >l#}&Je{I|j Qm<b,xT]N|(t^V&aYi8P͛ٲEEEԐTtN'zŇSRX-c(81+P>Fz@ ccƝ8U"ftV!iIH5dj1zb>3VB<z1H0h?3!2=i3D9hL,IeKGÓtη$!%tۻ@+#P"{YL[,{!_=8Oc^ȳ0<ƬtLK3f=˂0.!9};֬q-fqUCbA:;F5ír%A Av})>},.mTx穆,棗=c>Ka^/*~z>zo5ƍ*? Do4?8Yϟ/ЋrzŸ5HiD}X۟V*mX;Y]p+X ֓1f[o; ~V֞ 3|f>:SaVQϒcw1kYgUcO|Xƭ%­ <Ԅ0eub~:̾Ieu| JxyEawlq5;Iq15.U[_ٲsgƭ2SXmw~! DYd. y+ߌDƌAWzTzS/ߺ#Us}Gz\a96ɿ\xaي?.x$˒;a=jaY0CmHC>߹ qo€ 3ݡ}Ǻq׻kQ6v,w,4~FvR#w6r_ݡۍܛhۀ1ڣ~[ =BiJJ:h*rՙt*Rt ԊP#&O_#g㲐 d 㸞+i؋`&mFG] ߩt(Q#UsUP%:]Q F&{a.z,eZpڽ8ʝ3XiwLvw6-Gs-#]N׸;4Esܛi{%m'.S\]j{Um)bet@ m>Z4G]Bh?bjC54,zNnar #)״#2r4 R39E;ͨ~8.* }H j:LQ0Q_" tƺ=e\ O/*ƽ wM]mƯ7QRשFY\ W$\ih$GtBߌku,z}/nҝk'ܪ{7^\zޯbg]2l?x~['כI]0UŘnQӷQ} j?M oPLj1ޢVj*QNWz \V٘:c?Ot|AqjSU8G5R\K\RSx؀gL11|#YafΗu?MAΖ{uO_wu(,yJguKu3rt: !Ѝ s_H]= yH>^nWdFr,{\TOLyL*UY#Y#a6fOH1ʞ{=}aFZstv/Ó vr&xe?2=F:K%_g5Q'nĮM S#/w7 HK(2NLG+z2/dF!l֊:5:16*$J2he_Thq玡˼'glP͊ as |w6._0bsBl~/eR}X5zlNO4:=/ˢ>9E06ob3> "QIuz54wb>,Z cs+U8g|Xȇ}JyJC^I1N/b>LU+W8˸wfzI)!s__V{jɳ 'bw0հ(ggS(IL sqظ]08yf3֧9yg3lrF yA$;Sŝ"甉A#D':p:h*NB!ڛ0h 3FQ]8D"g;_;kg6nqFk{sp,.Ǚ\o?Cjgׁ#iXkfB{k $[_*ӭ-bGtNTc86N,wsrgc66n_Q>Fq8N3TyMZ1Q,I\a X 1qn0m :pJr8.N{8\L&e r v8d,2{~'Op!iv2NQ(vng >'Zkx ZDuTd';?-C|i5{3>cl}WXEwx%+Qv-VsdRkjeT}=NmNW/ZEb[ 1,̌sqe;r[JnWܦ9M#u;}U+.7S'NcXck;pon]Qz_sFNC\5 Ȕ2rU,Jk2fZ VhatV]`㜆noM]ޢjJl՗[tb\kpUg;#JeQgAA&B"/ D!L D`@AޑHyC"` ;-%P7cFtɬܻ:}soy G%NSЙ8guǩr$ZX8;Z! #"ܮwn/#` ^StPK`'wOܣhqќ2?zثO.Pgtn f:[Tos>pv qy`7h}`6 U\T笳UΉ[rUg '0{ 'H:n(Z>CۇpWUj4<>![rdb阄x/c ^B: /{+^eD߁ƨzE7#Hu S_Spa+5J-%).=)Ol;9jFI-J/D9C3hESsV`6w04gq&c3+Iig8q?g3$:J? TY(uR3JT̢O,:,3RY9\;9:q ;mU=~@5*;S]q/%ȑ2_]ՇNR_p߯s89 n͍'c\rMyx.I JMei{Ix"b>A r=]qA/UE (>@ͻ((Ki1ojZŴ:Χ >7hOL F,]tb~>YϽTȉT-)dh7|ƍiI#= Ao- 7Hy8||E5x} pGcFC1~npS>n+Ļh6B[ KϢ& _FXdY.s OI9E #.B &ԢKP!vmD<3eo x1R1c6=\" ;)=NR;|Mmw*FR"5)'HMur_Bm(@s-ZIh aTI/Ya^=4kR>ו#rhGS܊dɊs$w܉qn;&+JM>wbp2$*q;>ͭ'ph7Ľpp}qnC ]t7Mn:t_=dΠlZΥey'd./(w` 7rn% rdsEB\Q3帽0U~-c3x M0V ? S83x!fs!92 _kK7b#oފ}M]¿b4sP\X㌧-4cSNFgl&Sֻ-*b,&F8d[\k8/g싵9[;2u+<9`7QY"#6Zv.Ƥ,k~hݵ"¦u\bH-Z\.xN|+6Gul5k{%#c+b[<c?GبpcvWH29[<ؘng挹xa|7s8,m'6>wwfgԡF9:QDAY?=w*.44' z)a'+c0ڨ5+~tƌfS\kXu%VGW_Ztwcݪ5'65Ikt2&ͯY'lǘC Mk:bu9ͯX]A s&#섘hɚ=hlcH¢|{+&^"e~_2蝮gا K65g>0f\ILhܕ9b8"k ƔcfvFniY638O[IhfqfnJKQ1U! 㼅!!xۨ VpWJyRqۍ^ ǼC8AK|> x;K( ;>> ހ`=AAK)3vJ^*.  \G]F d=AYg5j6n*PQ.xۈ$o V ^ 9Cd}or:~_ */Luz,VxW%zo-yz+k]wy Ac1l_b>t%8"8OJNT)+X'Xo4 ^7aCux_ t~~by۟4@?T"0OT__*}I]@Wջk5jܠQK/E][|4sPBh=e< +Iz`ڷAH| TH &AxUEUu+;. A"H A "Ar0D $ A$$ɠ H#($Iuu}>U]ݧOuW.ZHDRZ7rMuA/[r'hH䆹 [{>l3I.)x(rϙ;ijnkl9m<-EGADj;qWA,%mR?ݶ[a656xMmN0dӂnyq2L3vn sFf2װܤ L:إ&]eL~B=lnz.uEܾMMl;jhS=dыv UIEz~Iyf7QFRo~Uя=[2*Mv􍤧DIM%KIn\e)\qSBA.Q4M k2Wd(.YI# $'6KQ+ d,>Ř+{0Kc5TW6ы*n*+(VSNS.(\ /P <_S[D[" 9#M4OpCԏQwMxԌWS#zgR-^q4YXRdzWbǗKyrTPY:5m lh6vC)sj:%sV<zX"I]flry$w((;+P\JDiI@Y2]+I*VJ;p L2QEID%\( z{Q5NT5wJ܉:J펅c5:ggw*pۋ$qgF s'3F?>c\iSHfR86ww_x;ˉ$pGO| n_u[9mf7qjc~TyB)ra?J~;% 57M̟wEn6&"|!|N-6JU6k\P7I}.έvIJFwFˑBrي)[]l;ڶg78pnt]^:fl^>eE>|wjGvomfvodwze/eT6&n caJtυH\xRʅR9,eR;-p J4JMRNB-uLR'L!\-+Gt_qp ?ag spa_oƇӿk}M^y/]|1]縮/̕\Ե}3+Wݳ|.w"/]IJWGJ/Ww\}n9Wwmq. Iy9vQ-D7C<_EGR_}(ǹ53"(=ô)ȇZfKR&GxRm1"JiF4GƬAo"Gkt4C%0hF{Mc3Qьf22SiFLg,3y&4Z VE jZOt&'R34NuM$18KВӃ?vr' лPZϣh-ʣBnO9;v]sR&IJv(4'24Ns590Ye!˧"VͤސzO"Rrȓ\H!Yq3j>7RCX˂ L8-RM8?lZ/'NK')#) 6S.,|C00*a0F/jޢ>h@C G *h#Jӷ(AgQ~A2Ki0eUT\P]*NoSu2UTPmGh%5%R:N= 4D/#yȨ(o֙KE*†KrZ.Y\_*UWn}9\J+nX۝88XN)WをKH tuz[sr:k~j*_A]a})G1}d|1^ܼy5Wǟ5+\k~y^~/侨ǽѐ{ ǣMreG{Hp*Ly<_hNgh7+xViceM᯾gkl$vG8&QjZm (9iHlJ`#^saOc=D{~݅3v;-b7WH![ʳJʕVmT"(n|ɥdUbTNLԧYBH=6#vlsa} lQ,1 Sm+LJ~9 G#WF(ƟB;vtٯD7=\aC}>1ʏD?QGbBYWߢ~OA? |Kq̯q'6rZ)k(DZ6ܦ,0+ÁXҰocAXsZVyLc1:| C10̎ƠUԨ@С|(<2r2}9#끯Vy>4cψ#bώ>zcuJ/ u8߭" !1 i8@8Normal <<CJOJQJmH F@F Heading 1$x@&5B*CJOJQJD@D Heading 2$x@&5CJOJQJ6@6 Heading 3$@& 5B*CJ22 Heading 4$@&5>*00 Heading 5$@&>*<A@<Default Paragraph Font0B0 Body Text$a$CJZPZ Body Text 2& x5$7$8$9DH$^ ` CJOJQJ, @,Footer  9r <C"<Body Text Indent ^222 Footnote TextCJ8&@A8Footnote ReferenceH*TRT Blockquotehhdd]h^hCJOJQJhnH >>@b>Title$a$5B*CJ OJQJ:Qr: Body Text 35CJOJQJ&)@& Page Number,@,Header  9r (U@( Hyperlink>*B*$X@$Emphasis6 W@ Strong5 $        $ +$!#&$$$ &!t!8?@@?0(  B S  ?$  !!"%J%::Teresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 05 sense\Hand out 1 measuing and judging.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 05 sense\Hand out 1 measuing and judging.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out 1 sentence completion.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out 1 sentence completion.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out2 kidney maching debate.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out2 kidney maching debate.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out 2 kidney maching debate.docTeresa\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out 2 kidney maching debate.docIAGO European Consultants Ltd\\SERVER\F\Clients\CERN\Contract\Training Programme\Final Revised Training Programme\Topic 06 qualitative\Hand out 2 kidney maching debate.docGraham Attwell~Macintosh HD:Users:graham:Documents:Work files:Projects:Current Projects:cern:trainingprog:six:Hand out 2 kidney mac#63FA5.doc|v2wAqZlsΘX8mo Cuwj-x=j0ʞl22wke-;],*9WD A[w #_$f6+^l{w*^`.^`.p^p`.@ ^@ `.^`.^`.^`.^`.^`.^`.p^p`.@ ^@ `.^`.^`.^`.^`.@xh h^h`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh 8^8`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh p^p`OJQJo(@xh  ^ `OJQJo(@xh @ ^@ `OJQJo(o@xh  ^ `OJQJo(hh^h`56.hh^h`56CJOJQJo( @@^@`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o PP^P`OJQJo( hh^h`OJQJo(@xh h^h`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh 8^8`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh p^p`OJQJo(@xh  ^ `OJQJo(@xh @ ^@ `OJQJo(o@xh  ^ `OJQJo( @@^@`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o PP^P`OJQJo( @@^@`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o PP^P`OJQJo(@xh h^h`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh 8^8`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh p^p`OJQJo(@xh  ^ `OJQJo(@xh @ ^@ `OJQJo(o@xh  ^ `OJQJo(0^`0o(.h   ^ `OJQJo(h ^`OJQJo(oh ^`OJQJo(h | | ^| `OJQJo(h LL^L`OJQJo(oh ^`OJQJo(h ^`OJQJo(h ^`OJQJo(oh ^`OJQJo(@xh h^h`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh 8^8`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh p^p`OJQJo(@xh  ^ `OJQJo(@xh @ ^@ `OJQJo(o@xh  ^ `OJQJo(hh^h`CJOJQJo(^`CJOJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o PP^P`OJQJo(@xh h^h`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh 8^8`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(@xh ^`OJQJo(o@xh p^p`OJQJo(@xh  ^ `OJQJo(@xh @ ^@ `OJQJo(o@xh  ^ `OJQJo(<moAj-j0X$f|v2l22A[Cu^l{9WD #_ke-;Zls|}T@h ^`OJQJo($0%@C$P @GTimes New Roman5Symbol3 Arial7 VerdanaA& :TahomaArial3Times? Courier NewI WingdingsSymbol"1h&*jFۃG!20d CERN TrainingMichaelaGraham Attwell Oh+'0 $ @ L X dpx'CERN TrainingoERN MichaelaninichichNormalaGraham Attwello7ahMicrosoft Word 10.1@V@\@2@,"l"!G ՜.+,D՜.+,8 hp|  'NJM CERN Training Title 8_AdHocReviewCycleID_EmailSubject _AuthorEmail_AuthorEmailDisplayName'X'CERN Training Programme 7achristine@iago.eu.come  christine a  "#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=?@ABCDEGHIJKLMPRoot Entry F783!RData  q,1Table!M9WordDocument"SummaryInformation(>DocumentSummaryInformation8FCompObjX FMicrosoft Word DocumentNB6WWord.Document.8